A closeup shot of a person wearing a suit holding some cash in his hand
South Africa’s new two-pot retirement system, now in effect for over three weeks, has enabled individuals to tap into their savings with newfound flexibility. While this new structure was designed to offer greater accessibility for those needing funds, there’s a critical element that many may overlook: the tax implications. Early withdrawals from the savings pot, particularly, could result in a significant tax surprise, pushing individuals into higher tax brackets.
The Mechanics of the Two-Pot System
The two-pot system splits retirement savings into two portions. Two-thirds of the contributions are allocated to a retirement pot, which cannot be touched until retirement. This portion is intended for long-term financial security, enabling individuals to invest in annuities or similar products upon retirement. The remaining one-third is directed to a savings pot, which individuals can withdraw from annually to cover emergency expenses.
This system seems straightforward at first glance. However, many South Africans may not be aware of the potential tax consequences of tapping into their savings pot.
The Taxation Surprise
The key issue lies in the marginal tax rate—this is the tax rate individuals pay based on their income bracket. Actuarial specialist Paul Menge from Momentum Investments explains that any income, including withdrawals from the two-pot system, counts towards your total income for the year. Therefore, if your annual income is close to the top of your current tax bracket, withdrawing funds from your savings pot could push you into a higher tax bracket.
For instance, someone earning R600,000 annually could see their marginal tax rate increase from 36% to a higher rate if they withdraw a significant amount from their savings pot. This could result in a larger tax burden when the South African Revenue Service (SARS) conducts its yearly assessment in July.
This is where the “nasty tax surprise” comes into play. Even if your tax directive accounts for a certain amount when making the withdrawal, you could still owe more at the end of the tax year. The result? A potentially vicious cycle where you may have to withdraw more funds to settle your tax bill, leading to further increases in tax liabilities.
The Long-Term Implications
The issue with early withdrawals goes beyond immediate tax concerns. Tapping into your retirement savings early could have long-term consequences for your financial security. If withdrawals are not done strategically and only in cases of true emergency, individuals risk jeopardizing their future retirement outcomes.
Additionally, the economic impact on the country cannot be ignored. Early withdrawals have the potential to reduce the pool of savings available for long-term investments, which can slow economic growth. South Africa is already witnessing billions of rands being withdrawn under the new system, with most of it expected to flow into consumer spending rather than debt repayment or emergency expenses.
Financial Discipline and Building an Emergency Fund
Menge advises against withdrawing from the two-pot system unless it’s a genuine emergency. Not only does it affect your retirement plans, but the tax burden could outweigh the immediate financial relief. He suggests that the unpleasant experience of paying additional taxes might serve as an incentive for individuals to prioritize building an emergency savings fund outside of their retirement pots.
While the two-pot retirement system offers greater flexibility, it’s important to understand the tax implications and long-term risks associated with early withdrawals. Careful planning and financial discipline will be crucial for South Africans navigating this new landscape.
—
Source: IOL News
About Author
tshepisosishuba 
